For The Record

Submit birth, marriage and obituary records online.


PDF documents on this site require the free Adobe Reader:

Get Adobe Reader

Mubarak: When the police and military fail, hire a mob

posted by Tim Nafziger on 02/02/11 at 04:34 PM

Egypt angry day 02

Like many of you, I've been watching closely as the events in Egypt unfolded this week. When the protests first began on Tuesday of last week it seemed like it might be a brief flare up, quickly repressed like so many others. But momentum grew through the week and the brutality of the police proved ineffective in preventing mass protests after prayers on Friday.

Then on Saturday, the police left the streets and the media stories began to talk about "looting" and "lawlessness". It's clear now that the regime's hope was that things would get so chaotic that people would beg the police to come back. To encourage this, undercover police joined in the looting and thousands of criminals were released from jail according to Human Rights Watch (HRW). "Mubarak's mantra to his own people was that he was the guarantor of the nation's stability. It would make sense that he would want to send the message that without him, there is no safety,"said Peter Bouckaert, the emergency director at HRW.

But this tactic failed. In some cases, the demonstrators joined security forces in protecting museums from looters linked to Mubarak. What was remarkable on Monday and Tuesday, was the stories of people coming together to support one another and keep one another safe. The "neighborhood watch" groups sometimes sounded ominous with their golf clubs and makeshift weapons, but read this description yesterday from Democracy Now correspondent, Sharif Abdel Kouddous, who is on the ground there:

But, you know, the regime continues to try and quell this uprising. And every movement it takes only creates more solidarity amongst the people and more—more solidarity amongst them that this regime must go, that it doesn't care about the country, that it would like to let the country go to ruins before it will release its grip on power. [The protestors] have seen that in the looting. They've said, "How can he let just all security go away and let people loot?" They've formed their own committees, these neighborhood committees, which are very organized now all across Egypt, and there's been very little crime. Egypt is reborn in this way. Egyptians have come together to claim this country, and they're going to continue to do so until Mubarak leaves. (from Millions Against Mubarak: Democracy Now!’s Sharif Abdel Kouddous Reports Live from Tahrir Amid Massive Protest)

Of course, the army has been a presence since the weekend, but they have remained remarkably neutral or even sympathetic to the protestors in some cases. The army was cheered when the arrived in contrast to the police who are widely reviled for their use of torture and repression. One video even seems to show the military protecting protesters from the police.

Mubarak mobs systematically take back Liberation Square

All this brings us to today when Mubarak supporters, including men on camel and horseback, arrived to systematically clear Tahrir square. The eye witness description of their strategy from The Atlantic sounds chillingly well planned:

 

The pro-Mubarak group flooded the square, and its strategy became clear: All the entrances to the plaza were being probed and, if found lightly defended, overrun. I was now on the outside among the forward surge; no one was permitted to leave, but a trickle of captured protesters came out, each surrounded by at least a hundred screaming Mubarak supporters, and being beaten so intensely that I couldn't see their faces, only a circle of waving sticks and fists, raining down on whatever unfortunate was at the center. One female protester was brought out, thrashed, and delivered to a military unit inside the Egyptian Museum grounds.

 

This is not political expression, these are the actions of thugs coordinating with plain clothes police officers. They are playing the same role that the paramilitaries do in Colombia. When the military and the police can't get it done, send in death squads. Here's a quote from a harrowing phone interview from a woman in the square just a few hours ago describing the attack:

They are coming in government cars... all of them are undercover police. We don't have a single ambulance. There are hundreds and hundreds of wounded. Mubarak didn't send protestors, he sent mercenaries... It's a massacre of unarmed women and children and people who are demonstrating for their rights.

At this point, the questions turn to the international community. Will they back up their words and withdrawal military aid from Egypt? Or will they sit idly by while Mubarak unleashes the chaos that he claims is the only alternative to his dictatorship.

Here's a quote from Noam Chomsky on today's broadcast of Democracy Now:

The United States, so far, is essentially following the usual playbook. I mean, there have been many times when some favored dictator has lost control or is in danger of losing control. There's a kind of a standard routine—Marcos, Duvalier, Ceausescu, strongly supported by the United States and Britain, Suharto: keep supporting them as long as possible; then, when it becomes unsustainable—typically, say, if the army shifts sides—switch 180 degrees, claim to have been on the side of the people all along, erase the past, and then make whatever moves are possible to restore the old system under new names. That succeeds or fails depending on the circumstances.

And I presume that's what's happening now. They're waiting to see whether Mubarak can hang on, as it appears he’s intending to do, and as long as he can, say, "Well, we have to support law and order, regular constitutional change," and so on. If he cannot hang on, if the army, say, turns against him, then we'll see the usual routine played out. Actually, the only leader who has been really forthright and is becoming the most—maybe already is—the most popular figure in the region is the Turkey's Prime Minister Erdogan, who's been very straight and outspoken.

This is a reminder that Obama's support for Mubararek and lack of concrete action is consistent with decades of U.S. foreign policy. Chomksy points out that Obama's speech last night was empty platitudes and puts the responsibility for propping up Mubarak squarely in the lap of the United States:

The U.S. has an overwhelmingly powerful role there. Egypt is the second-largest recipient over a long period of U.S. military and economic aid. Israel is first. Obama himself has been highly supportive of Mubarak. It's worth remembering that on his way to that famous speech in Cairo, which was supposed to be a conciliatory speech towards the Arab world, he was asked by the press—I think it was the BBC—whether he was going to say anything about what they called Mubaraks authoritarian government. And Obama said, no, he wouldn't. He said, "I don't like to use labels for folks. Mubarak is a good man. He has done good things. He has maintained stability. We will continue to support him. He is a friend." And so on. This is one of the most brutal dictators of the region, and how anyone could have taken Obama's comments about human rights seriously after that is a bit of a mystery. But the support has been very powerful in diplomatic dimensions. Military—the planes flying over Tahrir Square are, of course, U.S. planes. The U.S. is the—has been the strongest, most solid, most important supporter of the regime. It's not like Tunisia, where the main supporter was France. They're the primary guilty party there. But in Egypt, it's clearly the United States..

Just go watch or read the whole thing on Democracy now: Noam Chomsky: “This is the Most Remarkable Regional Uprising that I Can Remember”

Image by Muhammad Ghafari [Wikimedia Commons

Monday, 2/7/11 Update: The latest strategy seems to be bad faith negotiations in which Omar Suleiman makes false claims about the result of negotiating sessions that none of the other parties agreed to:

Yesterday, with the round of negotiations, or so-called dialogue, that he had with some representatives of political forces, again, it became very clear that [Suleiman] does not enter these negotiations on an equal footing with representatives of the protesters. He sent everyone home and then decided to deliver a statement of what he called a consensus that resulted from these consultations. And later, we had a number of political—of representatives of political forces, most importantly the Muslim Brotherhood, saying, "That is not true. You know, we did not agree to these things. This was only a protocol session. It is the first session of this dialogue. Each one of us expressed their views, and then we were told that we will be invited back. And suddenly, we were surprised to see Suleiman announcing the understandings or agreements, as he called them, to Egyptian television."

This quote is from an interview on Democracy now with Hossam Bahgat. Bahgat is an "Egyptian human rights activist and the founder and executive director of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights."

The interview also gives a more in-depth look at Suleiman's history. If Suleiman replaced Mubarak it could be an even worse situation for the Egyptian people given his history as an architect of repression and authoritarian methods of control.

Nafziger_tim_2_thumbnail Tim Nafziger is passionate about gathering people with shared values to work together for change in our communities and our world. One such space is Christian Peacemaker Teams (CPT) where he works as interim assistant director. Tim lives with his wife Charletta in the Ojai Valley in southern California where they connect with Bartimaeus Cooperative Ministires. Tim has written chapters in Widening the Circle: Experiments in Christian Discipleship; Fear or Freedom?: Why a Warring Church Must Change; and 118 Days: Christian Peacemaker Teams Held Hostage in Iraq. His photo portfolio is at timnafziger.com. You can follow Tim on Twitter at @tim_nafziger

Reader Comments

Add Comments
  • Posted by PA Mennonite at Friday, February 11, 2011 at 01:24 PM

    I question whether we really should be so optimistic over this development. Consider the following from Pew Research as reported in Investors Business Daily: Among highlights from the Pew poll: • 49% of Egyptians say Islam plays only a "small role" in public affairs under President Hosni Mubarak, while 95% prefer the religion play a "large role in politics." • 84% favor the death penalty for people who leave the Muslim faith. • 82% support stoning adulterers. • 77% think thieves should have their hands cut off. • 54% support a law segregating women from men in the workplace. • 54% believe suicide bombings that kill civilians can be justified. • Nearly half support the terrorist group Hamas. • 30% have a favorable opinion of Hezbollah. • 20% maintain positive views of al-Qaida and Osama bin Laden. • 82% of Egyptians dislike the U.S. — the highest unfavorable rating among the 18 Muslim nations Pew surveyed. Are these attitudes the kind of change we are championing as Christians and Mennonites, or are we caught up in the buzz from the predominant media outlets?

  • Posted by timjn at Monday, February 14, 2011 at 12:35 AM

    PA Mennonite,

     

    What political solution are you proposing that Christian and Mennonites should be championing in Egypt right now?

     

    Also, you misquoted the poll. The Pew Research Center only surveyed Muslims in Egypt for their study. That means the opinions of the 10% who are not Muslim were not included at all in the statistics you quoted. Here's the original survey: http://pewglobal.org/2010/12/02/muslims-around-the-world-divided-on-hamas-and-hezbollah/

  • Posted by PA Mennonite at Monday, February 14, 2011 at 08:56 AM

    I was not proposing that we need to champion any political solution (isn't that novel?) Those who championed the overthrow of the Zimbabwean govt. in the 1970's in favor of Mr. Mugabe and his land revolution have egg on their face, not? Those who threw off the Czars in Russia unleashed an uncontrollable political beast. My point is that a good many revolutions end up with the populace in worse shape then when they started. Who was the puppet master oft his one? In the end we shall see. Perhaps we, as Anabaptist Mennonites, should have no opinion because the future is always a fog, and not be vested in the outcome beyond trusting in God's providence.

  • Posted by nikood at Sunday, July 07, 2013 at 10:55 PM

    Wonderful job. Thanks. hermes kelly 35

  • Posted by wendylowhy at Sunday, February 02, 2014 at 12:02 AM

    this is one of the best articles on this website. definitely excellent information and hope to read more. awesome. this is the information i have been searching. Ecopolitan Ecopolitan Executive Condominium Tembusu Tembusu Condo Tembusu Kovan Vue 8 Sea Horizon Sea Horizon Executive Condominium Rivertrees Rivertrees Residences Rivertrees Condo Rivertrees Condominium Rivertrees Residences Fernvale Rivertrees Fernvale Ladies Bags Ladies Bag Ladies Handbags Designer Bags Handbags Shoulder Bag Designer Handbags Thanks for sharing information that is actually helpful

  • Posted by wendylowhy at Saturday, April 26, 2014 at 09:42 AM

    Thanks for sharing information that is actually helpfulgreat. keep blogging the good stuff. this is one of the best articles on this website. definitely excellent information and hope to read more. awesome. this is the information i have been searching. Bags | Bag | handbags | handbag | Ladies bags | Shoulder bags | Pollen & Bleu | Pollen&Bleu| Pollen and Bleu | pollen bleu | pollen & Bleu residences | pollen & Bleu singapore | farrer drive condo | coco palms | coco palm | coco palms condo | coco palm condo | coco palms pasir ris | pasir ris condo | the rise @ oxley | the rise@oxley | the rise @ oxley residences | the rise at oxley | the rise at oxley residences | oxley rise residences | oxley rise condo | rise @ oxley | rise at oxley Thanks for sharing information that is actually helpful

  • Posted by Meela at Wednesday, May 28, 2014 at 12:18 AM

    Hello, i am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited and happy to say that the webmaster has done a very good job here to put all the information content and information at one place. cyberbola.co/ibcbet

  • Posted by Meela at Wednesday, May 28, 2014 at 12:30 AM

    Great blog! I really love how it is easy on my eyes and the information are well written. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which really should do the trick! Have a nice day! tendang.net tendang.net/jadwal-bola