We can be self-critical without disdain
by John A. Lapp, Akron, Pa.
I was much interested in the several paragraphs in the Nov. 4 editorial “What Good News?” on Mennonite “self-loathing.” I have occasionally seen references to Jewish “self-hatred.” I don’t recall seeing “self-loathing” identified as a Mennonite malady before. In this editorial, Everett Thomas is on to an important topic.
I have wondered whether the disdain that some “progressive” Mennonites have for conspicuously conservative sisters and brothers represents a kind of self-loathing. I have also wondered whether the dropping of the Mennonite label by some congregations represents a similar “lack of self-confidence.” The label change sometimes represents a strong desire to be missional—without recognizing that all labels, including “Christian” or “nondenominational,” also have difficult baggage. Former Mennonites sometimes express such disappointment with their past history, which appears to be a form of shame.
Thanks for calling attention to this weakness in our self-perception. If there is to be a continuing Mennonite identity in the 21st century, we need to find meaning in our tradition, its uniqueness and significance clearly articulated and affirmed. We can be self-critical without being disdainful. The Mennonite ought to work on defining a meaningful identity that is more than self-promotion and self-congratulation.
Associated Issue: Welcome all abilities - Dec. 2, 2008
Associated Article: What good news?
Current Stories
Articles
News stories, digests and Meno Acontecer
- WEB EXCLUSIVE: A modern Christmas story
- Preach-off raises $2,994
- Top 10 stories for Mennonite Church USA in 2008 include rescue, student deaths
- MCC braces for coming economic storm
- Online registration soars for Columbus 2009
- CPT begins three-month project in Congo
- MEDA expands service for microfinance
- Vietnam Mennonite Church legalized
- MCC launches Seed program for young adults
- MC USA leaders visit two Congo groups