For The Record

Submit birth, marriage and obituary records online.


PDF documents on this site require the free Adobe Reader:

Get Adobe Reader

2011-02-01 issue:

Confessions of a modern day pacifist

What should pacifism look like today?

by Lisa Schirch

Print Article


The death of Mennonite Central Committee worker Glen Lapp in Afghanistan last
August raises questions about pacifists working in war zones without armed guards. I stayed with Glen and other MCC workers at a small guesthouse during my visits to Afghanistan to teach peacebuilding at Kabul University.

Glen Lapp (left) with the author. Photo provided.

On my first night in Afghanistan I lay in bed watching my breath coil above me in a heatless room, hovering around 30 degrees F. All night, I listened to the calls to prayer from the local mosque and felt the vibrations of helicopters overhead. In the morning, I stood at my room's bay window trying to figure out if I could prevent the cold air from blowing in or stop the windows rattling with every helicopter passing overhead. That's when I realized the window of my ground-floor room did not have a lock. More than feeling the cold or hearing the noise, I felt afraid. After struggling unsuccessfully to get the window locked, Glen concluded, "It doesn't really matter; we don’t lock the front door to the house either."

To be fair, the guesthouse is in a cement-walled compound with a locked gate. But that night, as I stared at the ceiling, I thought, This is pacifism circa 2010. Most of the other foreigners in the city have machine guns and soldiers between them and the Afghan streets. I remembered the story of Pennsylvania Quakers in the 1700s who kept their doors unlocked at night to send a peace signal to the Natives (who, by the way, were referred to as terrorist insurgents back then) waging war against the new, often violent settlers who were taking their land.

What is pacifism?
Pacifism, as I understand it, means most literally “lover of peace” in Greek. But more specifically, in the Christian tradition, pacifism focuses on living without harming others at the minimum and as much as possible loving enemies and doing good to those who harm you.

Pacifism assumes that punishment and retribution do little to bring about change and tend to escalate the cycle of violence. It is not moral or even possible to “kill all the bad guys.” It is only possible to identify and address factors leading to violence in the environment, such as unemployment. As a pacifist there are causes for which I am prepared to die but none I can imagine that would lead me to kill.

The U.S. military is a scapegoat for many U.S. pacifists. Condemning military aggression is easy; we point fingers at other people who do harm. There are not many pacifist efforts to love people in the military.

Yet many new military leaders are starting to preach that, counter to traditional military strategy, the "shock and awe" of dropping bombs does not grow peace; it creates more hatred, an endless cycle of violence. When U.S. soldiers faced an angry mob of Haitian youth after the earthquake, their leader ordered the soldiers to "take two steps back and sit down" rather than fire their weapons at the crowd. In turn, the surely surprised Haitian youth mirrored the soldiers and also sat down. Pacifism may not be intuitive, but military leaders know that nonviolent approaches can be ingenious when practiced bravely.

How do pacifists love those they disagree with?

A tale of Mennonite pacifism
I come from a long tradition of self-identified pacifists dating back to the 1500s in Switzerland, where my ancestors scratched my last name into the town castle’s torture chambers. Perhaps they were tortured for something less noble than pacifism, such as public drunkenness. As for many other Mennonites, pacifism has been a point of family conflict. In the last few generations, my Mennonite-born uncles and grandfather served in the U.S. military.

But the legends of early Mennonites loving their enemies made a profound impact on my psyche and professional life. My faith draws on images from the Martyrs' Mirror of Dirk Willems pulling the armed guard who was chasing him out of the frozen river, only to then be arrested and put to death for his beliefs. Or Janneken Munstdorp, who, shortly before being burned at the stake in 1573 for refusing to recant her belief in Anabaptist pacifism, wrote a letter to her children similar to the one I have written to my own children should anything happen to me while doing my work in peacebuilding.
Pacifism incarnate was difficult to imagine as a child. I lived an easy, peaceful life in rural Ohio. The moral ambiguities implicit in pacifism set in when, as part of Goshen (Ind.) College’s semester abroad, I worked in a Nicaraguan refugee camp’s health center tending the gangrenous wounds of Contra soldiers.

Listening to and cleaning the wounds of soldiers, some of whom had committed horrible atrocities against civilians in Nicaragua, where my brother documented such incidents with a group called Witness for Peace, was life changing. Before, good and evil had seemed like separate phenomena. But when you start to love people you disagree with, everyone starts looking a lot more like a human being doing the best they can with what they know and have experienced.

In the field of peacebuilding, we teach the skills and values of dialogue. We ask Christians, Jews and Muslims to sit together and share points of view. We ask Israelis and Palestinians to reach out across the political divisions. As a pacifist, it seems only natural to reach out to the U.S. military to understand different points of view and find common ground. Attending military conferences with a name badge identifying me as from "Eastern Mennonite University" leads to many interesting conversations about Mennonite pacifism.  My military colleagues admire Mennonite humanitarian work around the world. But they are curious about our antagonism with the military, noting the many contradictions and ambiguities of pacifism circa 2010.

Modern challenges to pacifism
When I landed in Iraq in 2005 with MCC, local partners provided an armed guard to me as I facilitated a peacebuilding and development training. Shrouded in a black headscarf, I sought to blend in. I asked my hosts if I could ride in the bus with the other Iraqi participants rather than in the Land Rover with the armed guard. My hosts graciously explained that actually I would put them in more danger to do so. The armed guard, it seems, was deemed necessary for the safety of the Iraqi participants in the workshop. As a Westerner, I brought greater attention and threat to them. So I accepted the armed guard. Did this betray my pacifism?

When an armed gunmen went into a school, tied up Amish girls and started shooting, the Amish called armed police to stop him. That moment illustrates so-called “two-kingdom theology,” the belief that there is God’s kingdom, where Mennonites practice pacifism, and there is the secular kingdom, where we need armed police to maintain law and order. Is it pacifist to ask someone with a gun to come deal with a man threatening Mennonite youth?

The Taliban have been going into schools around Afghanistan and shooting girls. In Afghanistan, nearly all of MCC’s partners support a U.S. military presence training Afghan police to protect civilians from the Taliban. Is there a difference between Mennonites calling the police when they are attacked in their homes or schools versus Mennonites supporting a U.S. military presence and police force to prevent Taliban attacks on girls' schools in Afghanistan?

Last year I spent an hour on a local talk radio program in Harrisonburg, Va., receiving hate-filled questions about Mennonite pacifists living in the Shenandoah Valley. Like some of my military colleagues, callers asked why Eastern Mennonite University will not fly the U.S. flag and why Mennonites are not willing to send their boys off to fight for the freedoms and privileges of living in this country. I explained how Mennonites risk their lives around the world, with equal sacrifice and dedication to the principles of freedom as military soldiers. But Mennonite pacifists have not communicated clearly our alternative versions of patriotism to show our love of the land we live in and the world we belong to.

Loving those condemning Mennonite pacifism means taking seriously their accusations of our contradictions and double standards. If the concept of pacifism is to be anything more than a quaint if naïve relic of the past, it needs some serious updating. 

In its 90-year history, MCC has only lost one person other than Glen to direct violence out of 19,000 field workers. Most pacifism today calls for far less sacrifice than giving one’s life in a war zone to help people.

Perhaps Glen Lapp's simple lifestyle as an avid bike rider and conscientious consumer says more about pacifism today than the loss of his life. Perhaps modern-day pacifism is about looking inward, at everyday choices of what we eat, wear, drink and how we transport ourselves in ways that respect land and people. Perhaps pacifism requires a tad less judgment of others we see as "harming" and more engaging our neighbors to build understanding and love for those different from us.

Lisa Schirch is professor of peacebuilding at the Center for Justice and Peacebuilding, Eastern Mennonite University, Harrisonburg, Va.

Reader Comments

Add Comments
  • Posted by Berry Friesen at Saturday, January 29, 2011 at 05:39 PM

    Yes, confession is good. But I wish Schirch had written a longer piece, one that begins to describe what she would regard to be a "serious updating" of pacifism. As it stands, the article seems to suggest that because of the "ambiguities" "contradictions" and "inconsistencies" of pacifism, it is only "a quaint if naive relic of the past." My suggestion would be that we reframe the discussion and focus on witness rather than rule-keeping. What would witness to Jesus and his Kingdom suggest with regard U.S. occupation of Afghanistan so that we can maintain our exalted standard of living? What would it suggest with regard to the propaganda that U.S. troops are in Afghanistan so that girls can attend school? What would it suggest in response to those who question our patriotism if we decline to be part of the deception and domination of the imperial project? However compromised we may be, yet as God is our help, we can bear witness to the light and we can bear witness against the darkness. "We are hard pressed, but never cornered; bewildered, but never at our wits' end; hunted, but never abandoned to our fate . . . . . " II Cor. 4:8

  • Posted by Lisa Schirch at Wednesday, February 02, 2011 at 11:48 AM

    Previous articles in The Mennonite express my concern for updating pacifism and what I think this means. Please see "Up, out, down" at this link: http://www.themennonite.org/issues/13-3/articles/Up_out_down And also "Redeeming the power, redeeming ourselves" at this link: http://www.themennonite.org/issues/10-21/articles/Redeeming_the_power_redeeming_ourselves

  • Posted by jhstomar at Monday, February 28, 2011 at 10:01 PM

    Very thought provoking. keep learning and teaching us.

  • Posted by francinegarcia at Monday, July 29, 2013 at 04:10 PM

    Thanks for sharing this with all of us. Of course, what a great site and informative posts, I will bookmark this site. keep doing your great job and always gain my support. This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. -buy you tube views

    -get more views youtube

  • Posted by kitkax at Sunday, October 27, 2013 at 08:48 AM

    Dear Lisa Schirch,

    Just wanted to tell you that you are doing an incredible job... I really do appreciate it very much... Thank you so much for everything and have an awesome day.

  • Posted by price4india at Monday, December 09, 2013 at 01:33 AM

    I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities
    www.price4india.co.in mobile

  • Posted by andyu at Saturday, December 28, 2013 at 01:14 AM

    Great!This article is creative,there are a lot of new idea,it gives me inspiration.
    brazilian hair

  • Posted by FawnBechtold75 at Thursday, January 09, 2014 at 03:32 AM

    Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site? I'm getting tired of Wordpress because I've had issues with hackers and I'm looking at options for another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform article free japanese po japanese tube japanese ex japanese po.

  • Posted by izolagotter at Friday, January 17, 2014 at 04:47 AM

    I'm not sure why but this web site is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? I'll check back later and see if the problem still exists japanese porn japanese sex japanese porn Japanese webcams Japanese sex chat.

  • Posted by izolagotter at Tuesday, January 21, 2014 at 10:06 PM

    I'm very happy to discover this great site. I want to to thank you for ones time due to this fantastic read!! I definitely liked every bit of it and i also have you book marked to see new things in your web site content writer seo content writing seo writing companies web content services custom writing services.

  • Posted by izolagotter at Sunday, February 09, 2014 at 08:47 PM

    You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually something that I think I would never understand. It seems too complex and extremely broad for me. I'm looking forward for your next post, I’ll try to get the hang of it! seo article writing services website content writing services professional writing services guest posting service web content writing services

  • Posted by OleviaConrad48 at Sunday, February 16, 2014 at 08:44 PM

    I blog quite often and I really appreciate your content. The article has really peaked my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information about once a week. I subscribed to your RSS feed as well seo content writers content writing services seo content writing seo content writing services web content development.

Current Stories

Articles

News stories, digests and Meno Acontecer

Columns

Births and Marriages

Readers Say


Subscribe